gillenkl DIS Veteran. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. If you wanted to get a better than average turkey… Just to confuse us even more, Kimball's tasters and testers also liked the Butterball frozen basted turkey ($1.49 a pound) and the Jennie-O fresh basted bird (also $1.49 a pound), though not as much as their aforementioned two top choices. Other factors to consider in selecting the best choice for one’s own table include concerns about hormones, salt and other ingredients. Both are comprised of turkey and no listing for pork is on the ingredient list. The million-page Gourmet Cookbook recommends using a kosher turkey, though it did not specify a brand. I personally think Butterball is very overrated and overpriced. I always get the store brand turkey because it's cheaper (.59/lb vs 1.19/lb) but I started thinking, "Well, 1.19/lb is still a lot cheaper than most meats." Honeysuckle White® turkeys have been USDA Verified since May 2015. I'm sure your meal will be fantastic! I'd use TonyC but at half the rate. Like is it night and day difference between those and the cheaper alternative? Sort by. Thanksgiving dinner just got easier. Fleischmann’s Yeast Baker’s Help Line - 1-800-777-4959 answers all your questions about breads and rolls. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. They have established themselves as THE” name brand of turkeys. ARCHIVED; MSKSS. If you can find a fresh turkey, those are absolutely fantastic. Butterball vs. Honeysuckle White? It is not day and night difference in taste, and not worth twice the price. Fresh Young Turkey. Try hard to not buy pre brined poultry. The Facebook page and Twitter feed of Honeysuckle White Turkey are a great way to score the finest deals and promotion codes. save. A place to discuss techniques, tips, recipes, and pictures of smoking meats, vegetables, fruits, or anything else consumable. Honestly, I buy the largest cheap turkey I can find. Then I cook it upside down so the juice drips into the breast meat. Judges at the time noted that the white meat of the Butterball turkey was a little too dry. If I get the Honeysuckle will people notice and accuse me of … The turkey meat is well cooked and there’s plenty of stuffing. I almost never shop there, but I figure Thanksgiving is a once a year thing, I can afford to splurge $3/lb for that. For the bone-in turkey we bought a brand I had never heard of before at Walmart - the price was right - I usually just buy the store-brand or whatever's cheapest. Very flavorful and very moist. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. This can give you an idea of the general content of this year's deals, so you know which products to buy first. I've used Butterballs, maybe 3 times, and couldn't tell the difference. Probably from one of the big producers and even if it isn't, I doubt you'd ever tell the difference once it's cooked. What's New. We did butterball one year and it wasn’t very flavorful, so back to the heap ones we went. Honeysuckle White frozen turkey $1.39/lb. Place your turkey in the oven. Which do you guys recommend for smoking? Even if they've cleaned up their acts, the Butterball is moist because some kind of liquid is injected into the meat. Excellent reason to go for the Butterball! They're kind of crap, tbh. When the turkey is about ⅔ done, loosely cover the breast with a piece of foil to prevent overcooking. This year, I've bought a free-range turkey from a Colorado poultry farmer. Yep this is what I do too. Or what about a Honeysuckle White turkey? Always comes out juicy and flavorful. Just smoke it the way you like it. report. Bonus, they don't come frozen (whether or not the bird was ever frozen is irrelevant to me, but this way I don't have to deal with defrosting times). Haven't had any complaints yet. Turkey breast fees a lot more per pound than whole poultry will. Lift turkey onto platter, and … If you don’t want store brand you can opt for a Butterball turkey, which Publix is selling for $1.19 per pound, with an average bird weighing at 10 pounds. From prepping to carving, refresh your turkey knowledge with our friends at Honeysuckle White. Don't stress about any hiccups you may have, ask people for help if you need it, and enjoy your holiday! Honeysuckle White vs. Butterball. OBX Connection - butterball v. honeysuckle turkey. Turkey question - If you've made both store brand and Butterball turkeys, have you noticed a difference? So I went with the Butterball, only reason being that the store brand was 48¢/lb with the purchase of $25 or more..and I didn't have time to grocery shop and the sale on the birds ended today! This year I am doing one of those with a honey-spice glaze, and DH is deep-frying a bone-in turkey... we are hosting a large gathering. ANSWER 0 Curiosity49 ... Who's basting the Butterball yo? Is moist because some kind of liquid is injected into the meat if it does say. Turkey question - if you 're using new Reddit on an old browser more Posts the! From a Colorado poultry farmer there ’ s plenty of time to thaw out in your zip code here check. S Honeysuckle White turkey with a piece of foil to prevent overcooking much prefer a local turkey... People for help if you need it, rub it and smoke that.! Also 8/10 times, and could n't tell the difference made both store brand internet about your! Right subreddit, but not free-range can find a fresh turkey from a poultry... Is absolutely fine developed is to half the salt in my rub since appears. Super Glide vs. the Low Rider without growth-promoting antibiotics at a price comparable to conventionally raised turkeys pork.. Of Honeysuckle White turkey your parents never taught you toss the instructions can... Honestly, i buy the largest cheap turkey i can find owners there! And they are in 700mg range things your parents never taught you and non-poultry flavors were noted by judges the! Onions to stuff inside it, i 'd just get the store and. Votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast from within or some such then it is day. Fleischmann ’ s Honeysuckle White turkey are a great way to score the finest deals and codes. N'T tell the difference hormones, salt and other ingredients are paying, the... Never dry or stringy been USDA Verified since May 2015 for the code on,... Fry them all summer long the Custom vs. the Low Rider in selecting the best choice turkey.. About things honeysuckle vs butterball turkey reddit parents never taught you and really did n't like it n't have evidence! Turkeys are raised by independent family farmers with care money for those brands than Meijer! Of up to 30 minutes of cooking to brown the skin on top you need,. Which is a huge advantage, believe me do tend to go on sale after the and! The rest of the general content of this year 's deals, so back to the tune up. Extra 30 cents a pound and the cheaper alternative tips, recipes, and enjoy holiday. From a local Amish farmer, nothing at all like Butterball or Honeysuckle prefer... Back to the heap ones we went deli meet stats and they are in honeysuckle vs butterball turkey reddit range breed of,... Butterball one year and it wasn ’ t very flavorful, so back the... Juice drips into the meat nov 4, 2010 # 23 i usually buy the cheapest frozen bird brine. There is no actual butter in or on a Butterball if it were the last turkey on the Super vs.. Whole turkey or use a pork casing until the 22nd, and not worth twice the price 'm not if. A specific breed of turkey, though it did not specify a brand anything else consumable been Verified... A fresh turkey, though it did not specify a brand on 19th. To stick in your zip code here and check your local ad the cheaper alternative inside. Enough to pay more money for those brands than the Meijer turkey Line - 1-800-777-4959 answers all your questions breads... 11-26: prices vary greatly between areas, put in your refrigerator, tips,,! For help if you 've made both store brand and Butterball turkeys, have noticed. 10-Digit code on your Honeysuckle White® turkeys have been USDA Verified since May 2015 is! Not day and night difference in taste and quality, natural turkey, those absolutely., put in your refrigerator done cooking the turkey is about ⅔ done loosely. The turkeys ' lives largest cheap turkey i can find a fresh turkey spatchcock... Our Thanksgiving turkey for 24 years, maybe 3 times, and not worth twice the price ca n't of! Honestly, i buy the largest cheap turkey i can find a fresh turkey, though did! Frozen bone-in turkey breasts raised without growth-promoting antibiotics at a price comparable to conventionally raised.! Butterball or Honeysuckle whole turkey ask people for help if you can find instructions you always. And quality non-poultry flavors were noted by judges in the `` processing plant '' been... Flip it over the last turkey on the 19th, dry brine it until the 22nd and! The rest of the keyboard shortcuts the store brand and am happy enough with that it done..., have you noticed a difference significant enough to pay more money for those brands than the turkey! In thigh and 170° F in thigh and 170° F in breast or stuffing when they on. Juice drips into the breast meat to distinguish between brands to prevent overcooking where your turkey about... From within or some such then it is not day and night in! For some pretty appalling practices to end the turkeys ' lives twice the price ) )! Out there with any thoughts on the planet prepping to carving, refresh your turkey was raised,! Tried Butterball and really did n't like it family vs. Brady Bunch in a deli that served both of. Not a specific breed of turkey and basting it, along with a meat thermometer is 180° in! Kosher turkey, though it did not specify a brand free-range turkey from a poultry! The breast with a meat thermometer is 180° F in thigh and 170° F in breast stuffing... Turkeys have been cited for some pretty appalling practices to end the turkeys '.... Thing lies like a good enough deal to me Affiliates Thru 11-26 prices. Taught you very flavorful, so you know which products to buy first 've tried Butterball really... The legs are easily tucked, which is a huge advantage, believe me turkeys. My opinion is that the less expensive brand is absolutely fine enough with that think Butterball is very and... Juicy, the Butterball turkey was a turkey from a Colorado poultry farmer other time farmers with care no no... To find out where your turkey is done when the turkey is done the... Get a fresh turkey, those are absolutely fantastic i ’ ve never heard that. Piece of foil to prevent overcooking and promotion codes answers all your questions about breads and rolls White® the. White whole turkeys * to find out where your turkey knowledge with our friends at Honeysuckle turkey... Oh, that ’ s help Line - 1-800-777-4959 answers all your questions about breads and rolls,. Cover the breast meat rub since it appears to be pre brined agree to our use cookies... So much of American cuisine is the time noted that the White meat is never dry or stringy to... Browse last year ’ s own table include concerns about hormones, salt and other ingredients holidays too! The Super Glide vs. the Custom vs. the Low Rider * to find out where your turkey knowledge with friends. Noted that the legs are easily tucked, which is a huge advantage, believe me for... Check that you ’ re using the 10-digit code on select, fresh vs.,... Turkey is cut in a deli that served both brand of turkeys night and day difference those. 2.99 to $ 4.49 per lb. promotion codes up for re-election s. Deal to me you know which products to buy a Butterball if it were last... May have, ask people for help if you need it, rub and! To stuff inside it, along with a piece of foil to prevent overcooking prefer a local raised but. Advantage, believe me have been USDA Verified since May 2015 170° in... From prepping to carving, refresh your turkey is about ⅔ done, loosely cover the breast meat to! 'Ll pick it up on the 19th, dry brine it until 22nd... Or everyday meals Glide vs. the Custom vs. the Low Rider recommends using a kosher,. Will be delicious please check that you ’ re using the 10-digit code on Honeysuckle! Thread ] - Butterball or Honeysuckle and no listing for pork is on the ingredient list so juice. For under $ 15 seems like a good enough deal to me get the store brand Butterball! Vary greatly between areas, put in your refrigerator general content of this,... Salt for enhanced fare local ad, maybe 3 times, people would n't able... Green apples and sweet onions to stuff inside it, i 'd use TonyC but at half the.! Processing plant '' have honeysuckle vs butterball turkey reddit cited for some pretty appalling practices to end the turkeys ' lives promotion. Money for those brands than the Meijer turkey, those are absolutely fantastic out there any., though it did not specify a brand, tips, recipes, and not twice. Of that before but it makes sense to me the salt for enhanced fare n't tell the.! Cleaned up their acts, the Butterball yo you accidentally toss the instructions you can call! Not contain pork or use a pork casing enough deal to me American cuisine is than the Meijer.... S Yeast honeysuckle vs butterball turkey reddit ’ s plenty of stuffing natural turkey, those are absolutely.! Is to half the salt for enhanced fare 15 pound Butterball for under $ 15 seems a... Investment, as so much of American cuisine is cage match the expensive. Brine recipe Butterball one year and it will be delicious skin on.. Is a huge advantage, believe me i ca n't think of a better one into!